Donyale Luna: Her Untouchable Imagination
Donyale Luna: Supermodel (2023) follows Luna from Detroit to the covers of Harper’s Bazaar and British Vogue, where she made history as the first Black cover model. Directed by Nailah Jefferson, the documentary explores how Luna reinvented herself and challenged fashion’s ideas about beauty.
America had already told Black women what beauty looked like. It had told them whose face belonged on a magazine cover, what sort of ambition was reasonable, how high they could go before somebody reminded them where they came from. Hear it often enough and one day, when you look in the mirror, you might hear it in your own voice.
Donyale Luna came from the moon. What was she supposed to do with any of that?
That’s the woman who fascinates me in Donyale Luna: Supermodel. She has the quality I love in a villain. You can explain the entire system to her, and she’ll listen just long enough to work out which part applies to her. Then she’ll get dressed and go wherever she was going.
She gave herself somewhere to live
In Detroit she was Peggy Ann Freeman. She came from a violent household with a strict mother. The boys called her ugly. Too tall, too skinny. She looked like an alien, they said.
When the British photographer David McCabe saw her in Detroit, she was wearing her school uniform. She was nearly six feet tall. He saw beauty and potential in the very things the boys had laughed at. He told her to come to New York.
She made up a name, gave herself an accent and let the story of where she came from change with the telling. She called herself a melting pot. There was room in Donyale Luna for all the things Peggy Ann Freeman had yet to discover.
By the time Luna got to New York, she expected to be a star soon. She found her way into Andy Warhol’s Factory, into films, into rooms where people wanted to make things with her. Warhol was taken with her. Richard Avedon wanted to photograph her exclusively. In 1965, Harper’s Bazaar put an illustration of her on its cover, a first for a Black model.
New York had the pleasure of Wonderland. Every time she followed something that interested her, there seemed to be another room. And for a while, you can feel how much fun she was having finding out what was in each one.
Then America remembered its rules
People objected to seeing a Black woman in those pages. A photographer could want her in his studio and someone else could make sure the picture never ran. All of a sudden, people who’d never worked with her had a say in how much work she could do.
This is where the identity box matters. The industry could restrict her work. To make its verdict part of her identity, it needed her cooperation. It needed her to go home and imagine a smaller future.
She went to London.
There was a whole scene there running on the pleasure of breaking rules. Young people were deciding what they wanted to wear, what they wanted to listen to and who they wanted to look at. In March 1966, Luna became the first Black model on the cover of British Vogue.
The pleasure of staying in her world
Asked her favourite colour, Luna said yellow. Yellow was deceptive, she said, and so was she.
I love that she kept playing. Even an interview about her favourite colour could become part of the world she’d made. She could tell you a story about the moon or about her beautiful blue eyes. She had a right to enjoy herself while you tried to work her out.
Her alter ego protected something precious in her. The freedom to create the life she wanted. A world where she could experiment, perform, model and explore her artistic soul.
Her alter ego took her into rooms people, Black and white, could only dream of entering. The Rolling Stones. John Lennon. Mia Farrow. She was a proud alien. The boys in Detroit had meant it as an insult. She ran with it.
In her world, there was no room for struggle. While Black Americans were fighting for their civil rights, Luna was making history, one magazine cover at a time. In her own world, she was already a star. Outside it, she became one.
That’s the villain I can only respect. In the world she’d made, she was untouchable. Her imagination was her own. If you wanted to play in her world, you were welcome. If you wanted her to make herself smaller, you could keep talking. Your opinion was non of her business.
Luna died at thirty-three after what was reported as an accidental heroin overdose. There’s so much we can’t know about that last night. One thing was certain. She couldn’t be caged.
With Love,
Mara Michels